12 23Thu05232013

Settings

Font Size

Back Opinion Hotel fire

Hotel fire

  • PDF

THAT sure was a close call last Labor Day when the Royal Orchid hotel in Tumon had to be evacuated due to an electrical fire.

From all accounts, emergency responders were on the scene quickly to evacuate hotel guests and in just a little over an hour, the hotel was declared secure and guests were allowed to return to their rooms.

Still, if the Royal Orchid fire had been worse, would the Guam Fire Department have been capable of handling it?

Guam is fortunate in that we have rarely experienced the kind of high-rise building fires we see in the movies that is common in other parts of the world.

However, the number of high-rise buildings on Guam will surely continue to increase. There’s already a new hotel being constructed in the heart of Tumon and with the continuing progress of Guam, more high-rises can be expected.

Moreover, taller and newer buildings will have more complicated fire protection systems and this will require greater awareness on behalf of the Guam Fire Department.

We're sure GFD has developed procedures to deal with high-rise fires. But these plans could be several years old and may not have taken into consideration changes in building and construction technology.

Experts say high-rise buildings are challenging and complex environments for fire services because they pose difficult problems such as the time and effort required to ascend to the fire, the coordination of occupants on multiple floors, and the reliance on building standpipe systems for firefighting.

A study prepared for the Surrey Fire Service in British Columbia stressed that high-rise fires are unique in that they challenge many aspects of a fire service's preparation and capability simultaneously. As such, they are notorious for revealing weaknesses in fire departments.

Here on Guam, do we even have fire trucks capable of reaching fires in the top floors of our tallest buildings? Are our firefighters adequately trained to handle a 5-alarm fire in one of our island’s high-rise buildings?

These are valid questions that must be asked because our island is heavily dependent on tourism. Mismanage just one high-rise hotel fire in the center of Tumon and we will have bad word of mouth traveling through our tourism markets that Guam is incapable of handling a big hotel fire. That’s the kind of negative publicity that drives tourists away.

In addition, local businesses also have a lot to lose. Even Monday’s minor incident resulted in merchants complaining about three hours worth of lost business. What more if a major fire happens in the heart of Tumon, clogging up traffic and closing shops for hours.

We should count ourselves lucky that we haven’t suffered from such a disaster yet. However, GFD should take a pro-active approach and try to prepare itself for any eventuality. And GovGuam should help support GFD by giving it the adequate equipment and training needed. Our residents and tourists must know that GFD can protect them – where ever they may be.

Comments  

 
0 #3 johnsmith 2012-09-08 12:18
#

Why do Guam firefighters work 24 hr shifts ?..

Can they work 8 hr shifts ? 12 hr shifts ?

I am used to paying Gov Guam employees to sleep on the job, I have been doing that for decades, but at least they sleep at their desks....

.Do I buy the food for the firefighters also ?....

HASTA
 
 
+1 #2 Dave 2012-09-07 19:56
Unquestionably, a serious high-rise fire would find Guam fire department woefully lacking in firefighting capability. About all they'd be able to do for anything engulfed in flame above two or three floors would be watch it burn. As the editorial suggests, when it happens -- and it will -- it will deal a life-threatening blow to the Guam tourist industry. It's quite possible that a number of Japanese, Russian, Korean and yes, Chinese, could die in such a conflagration. If you don't think it can happen just wait. I agree with the other poster -- put the museum on the back burner -- where it should be in any case while Guam is broke -- and spend the millions on state of the art fire equipment and training.
 
 
+1 #1 john smith 2012-09-07 10:26
#

Good post.....

Guam used to have one (1) high rise fire truck that could reach the 4th floor. The lift broke and the truck was reduced to just another ground floor coverage. The lift had a broken part as the media stated and for a decade or more it was never ordered or installed.

The truck sat at Tamuning station. I may be offan inch here and there, so somebody smart jump in here.

Guam may never have high rise fire trucks. Imagine a 5 alarm on floors 10-25 and the water is out or low pressure. Do hotels have a reserve cistern below the ground ?...

Perhaps we need a qualified ( off island white boys ) to review our entire GFD.

Perhaps a modernized fleet of trucks instead of a new museum ?....

Are we better off now than we were 4 years ago ?....

.HASTA
 

Please Login to post a comment.